1 Jul 2007
Operatic mixed noticesI did not particularly enjoy the double bill of L’Heure espagnole and Gianni Schicchi at the Royal Opera House. The Ravel was well staged and quite amusing but Bryn Terfel seemed to be on poor form as the eponymous star of Puccini’s little piece. It was rather like a meal of canapés – I was still hungry afterwards for some real emotion. But quite the worst opera experience this year was a visit to Bratislava where Opera Slovakia staged an execrable representation of Lucia di Lammermoor. The problem was not just lack of budget, poor direction, static acting, tiny orchestra, and uncomfortable seats. It felt as though time had stopped some time in the early 1900s. It probably had – the interval wine was 1950s prices. The contrast with Vienna could not be starker as they are but a stone’s throw apart along the Danube. There at the Wiener Staatsoper I had luxuriated in a Swan Lake of sublime poise and musical accomplishment. The orchestra enjoyed itself as much as we did – and it showed. The previous night’s Tosca was merely adequate because Neil Shicoff has lost the masterly tenor lustre he once had. There was compensation in the Tosca of Eszter Sümegi, an Hungarian soprano of notable quality. The opera house itself was new to me and a Hapsburg jewel.An altogether different Tosca at the Bayerische Staatsoper starred the husband and wife team of Daniela Dessi and Fabio Armiliato. His tenor was rather stretched but she more than compensated as Tosca. Even more exciting was the Scarpia of Mark Delavan, a Canadian of rich promise. Götz Friedrich’s staging is all you can hope for in this Puccini masterpiece. The best opera experience this year was Der Rosenkavalier, also at Munich, where I wallowed contentedly and with chin a-quiver amid the angelic voices of Adrianne Pieczonka, Sophie Koch, and Diana Damrau. John Tomlinson played for laughs as Baron Ochs but looked and moved remarkably like Buster Merryfield as Albert in Only Fools and Horses. An appreciative audience loved it – as did I. The snack and beverage service is outstanding.
Home to classMarin Alsop, in her last season with the Bournemouth Symphony Orchestra, concluded with a semi-staged performance of Duke Bluebeard’s Castle. She began the evening with an introduction to Bartók’s music which was all the more interesting given my recent visit to Hungary. After the intermission the interpretation by Gustav Beláãek as Bluebeard and Andrea Meláth as Judith was probably one of the finest musical experiences in the Lighthouse (aka Poole Arts Centre) for many a year. It was world class, deeply moving, and totally accessible. I thought the standing ovation de trop but 800 punters loved it. Duke Bluebeard! Bartók! Who’d have thought it?
© Incisive Media Ltd. 2008
Incisive Media Limited, Haymarket House, 28-29 Haymarket, London SW1Y 4RX, is a company registered in the United Kingdom with company registration number 04038503